Uniquick vs John Guest

Moderator: Moderatoren

Antworten
Nachricht
Autor
Heering80
infiziert
Beiträge: 42
Registriert: 2013-05-22 19:50:08

Uniquick vs John Guest

#1 Beitrag von Heering80 » 2019-11-14 22:54:42

Hi,

It's time for us to think about the water system for our truck. It seems that there are at least two common piping systems in use, Uniquick and John Guest. JG is more prominent in the web, but which would you guys recommend and why?

When it comes to pumps, is Shurflo the way to go, or are there better value pumps available too?

My initial idea for a setup is:
FILTER -> TANK -> PUMP -> EXPANSION TANK -> HEATER -> TAPS (kitchen + toilet/shower). Is it good to have a single filter before the tank, or would it be better after it? I guess there should also be pressure gauges and drain valves here and there, but not really sure where and why 😂.

I have the selbstausbau dvd, but I'm writing in hope that someone would like to chat in english. If you know a good thread in german, please recommend it. I can translate it once I find one, but it seems to be difficult to find them using search.

Benutzeravatar
mdoerr
Schlammschipper
Beiträge: 418
Registriert: 2014-06-17 9:00:08
Wohnort: Northampton, Breitengüßbach, Одеса

Re: Uniquick vs John Guest

#2 Beitrag von mdoerr » 2019-11-15 8:53:15

It depends what material you want to use.
I used aluminium compound pipes. There are different manufacturers available at local DIY stores.

I'd recommend a different setup

Tank -> Pump ( -> optional UV treatment) -> Filter -> Taps

I use an Italian pump for 24V with pressure vessel all stainless steel. (Hauswasserwerk)

grijo
süchtig
Beiträge: 837
Registriert: 2007-01-22 17:33:29
Wohnort: Raum Esslingen

Re: Uniquick vs John Guest

#3 Beitrag von grijo » 2019-11-15 10:29:20

mdoerr hat geschrieben:
2019-11-15 8:53:15
...
I used aluminium compound pipes. There are different manufacturers available at local DIY stores.
...
Do you use coated aluminium pipes?
I used a small piece of uncoated Aluminium pipe in my Landrover and i got aluminium corrosion with the result of "white flakes" at the tap.
I then changed to copper pipe

Joachim

Benutzeravatar
siegerland
süchtig
Beiträge: 881
Registriert: 2015-06-06 9:02:52
Kontaktdaten:

Re: Uniquick vs John Guest

#4 Beitrag von siegerland » 2019-11-15 13:17:18

Hi, Kunstoff-Fittinge sind leichter als Metall-Fittinge, das spricht sicher dafür, die Kosten sind jedoch enorm.

Über die Pistentauglichkeit von Uniquick und JG kann ich keine Aussage machen.

Wir entschieden uns für Klemmringverschraubungen aus Messing und koppeln diese mit Mehrschichtverbundrohr (Tipp hier aus dem Forum!)

Bild

Damit sind vielfältige Anwendungen realisierbar und reversierbar. Die Vielfalt der Fittingtypen ist groß.


Gruß

Stefan

Benutzeravatar
Mister Catdriver
Schrauber
Beiträge: 370
Registriert: 2012-12-27 23:28:52
Wohnort: Wild-Westallgäu

Re: Uniquick vs John Guest

#5 Beitrag von Mister Catdriver » 2019-11-15 14:34:31

Hi,

our water installation is fitted with the uniquick System!
It is very easy and i would absolutely recommend it!
If its necessary to open or change any Connection, this is possible without Tools.

Joerg
„Sie wissen doch genau, dass solche Hupen in Deutschland nicht erlaubt sind!“

„Ja-aber da wo wir hinfahren brauchen wir die!“
- Franz Meersdonk - Folge 1-

Benutzeravatar
moje 57
abgefahren
Beiträge: 1155
Registriert: 2017-12-21 22:34:50
Wohnort: Neuruppin

Re: Uniquick vs John Guest

#6 Beitrag von moje 57 » 2019-11-15 18:04:17

Hi,
We have the Uniqick system. In the drinking water system, any brass or bronze is taboo. Especially when silver ions are to be used in drinking water hygiene, electrochemical corrosion can occur and cause problems.

Greetings,
Moje57

„Jeder soll nach seiner Façon selig werden.“ FR / F II

Benutzeravatar
Apolda13
LKW-Fotografierer
Beiträge: 147
Registriert: 2015-05-24 20:42:52
Wohnort: AP

Re: Uniquick vs John Guest

#7 Beitrag von Apolda13 » 2019-11-15 21:24:18

Ich kann Viega Sanfix Wasserleitungen mit Pressverbinder aus Rotguss und Hülsen aus Edelstahl empfehlen.
https://www.wohnmobil-selbstausbau.com/ ... AC-N_.html
Hält sicher und für Trinkwasser gemacht.

Heering80
infiziert
Beiträge: 42
Registriert: 2013-05-22 19:50:08

Re: Uniquick vs John Guest

#8 Beitrag von Heering80 » 2019-11-15 21:29:42

mdoerr hat geschrieben:
2019-11-15 8:53:15
I'd recommend a different setup

Tank -> Pump ( -> optional UV treatment) -> Filter -> Taps
Somebody thought that filtering all the water during tank filling would make sure that you only had clean water with you.. But is it so that water laying around in tanks gather some inpurities over days, and thus would be good to filter just before use?

Do you guys have an extra pump for sucking water from natural sources like lakes and streams? Or are you dependent on finding a pressurised water source?

Uniquick seems to have an upper hand right now..

Antworten